Tuesday, October 9, 2012

Sullivan Unhinged

That's how I describe Andrew Sullivan's most recent lengthy post on the President's campaign. The post was sparked by the latest Pew poll which shows Romney leading by 4 points after Pew had Obama ahead by 8 points a few weeks ago. Here's some of Sullivan's rant:
Look: I'm trying to rally some morale, but I've never seen a candidate this late in the game, so far ahead, just throw in the towel in the way Obama did last week - throw away almost every single advantage he had with voters and manage to enable his opponent to seem as if he cares about the middle class as much as Obama does. How do you erase that imprinted first image from public consciousness: a president incapable of making a single argument or even a halfway decent closing statement? And after Romney's convincing Etch-A-Sketch, convincing because Obama was incapable of exposing it, Romney is now the centrist candidate, even as he is running to head up the most radical party in the modern era.
OK, let's start by discussing that Pew poll in more depth.

The Pew poll is upsetting to many in large part because it is a pollster with a good track record and credibility. This top line caused Andrew Sullivan to descend into italics and exclamation points.
Before the debate, Obama had a 51 - 43 lead; now, Romney has a 49 - 45 lead. That's a simply unprecedented reversal for a candidate in October. Before Obama had leads on every policy issue and personal characteristic; now Romney leads in almost all of them. Obama's performance gave Romney a 12 point swing! I repeat: a 12 point swing.
Exclamation points!!! Italics too!!!

I've been arguing that the Romney bounce from the debate appears to have been about 3 points and that it appears it may be receding from that high. That still seems about right. One thing to notice about the Pew poll is that it was in the field on Oct. 4 to Oct. 7. But, as Mark Blumenthal points out, almost all of those interviews were on Oct. 4 to Oct. 6, when the Romney bounce was at its peak:
According to Pew Research, 1,046 of its 1,201 interviews were conducted on Thursday through Saturday. Just 155 interviews were conducted on Sunday. The full sample had a margin of error of 2.9 percentage points, with a 3.4 percentage point margin of error among likely voters.
So, this Pew poll is likely overstating Romney's actual support at this moment.

Also, it is one poll! Rasmussen has the race even (even this morning). Gallup has the race roughly even among likely voters. But beyond the polling, let me make a larger point about Andrew Sullivan's absurd reaction. If you are someone who thinks that 90 minutes of bad debating is going to cancel out 4 years of a record worth defending and months and months of bad campaigning by Romney, then you are someone who believes there isn't sufficient wisdom and virtue among the people for self-governance.

The polling (beyond the Pew Poll) doesn't suggest the race has been "thrown away." Get a grip Andrew.

Monday, October 8, 2012

Pew

As in "P.U. ... that Pew poll is bad."

Yeah, it is. Pew shows Romney ahead by 4 points among likely voters. Pew has generally had overly optimistic polls for Obama this cycle and that is more reason to be worried about this poll. On the other hand, there is something wrong when a pollster swings so wildly.

So, the reality is, I'm just not sure what to make of this poll.

Gallup's "Latest"

Yahoo News has a story right on their homepage (updated a little over 2 hours ago) that says
The latest Gallup tracking poll conducted in the three days immediately following last week's first presidential debate between Mitt Romney and Barack Obama shows the race tied - with each candidate currently garnering 47 percent support among registered voters. Tracking conducted in the two days leading up to the debate showed President Obama with a five point lead - 50 percent to Mitt Romney's 45 percent.
This would be breaking news if it were actually now ... ya know, breaking. It's actually almost 2 days old.

Go to Gallup's site and you'll see that their "latest" polling release has Obama up 50-45, better than the 49-46 margin he had yesterday and the day before. Gallup's tracker does not yet have a full 7 days since the debate so Obama's numbers may well deteriorate from here once we get the full post-debate set of interviews. But it is just not true to say that the story above is "the latest."

Rasmussen's tracker this morning shows Obama and Romney tied 48-48, better than Romney's 2-point lead yesterday. I noted yesterday that Romney's post-debate surge seems to have crested. Both these polls are consistent with that view.

Mark Blumenthal is up with an article this afternoon explaining the Gallup mess for laypeople. Read that if what I've said above is unclear. But importantly, he points out that Romney's bounce may well be fading at this point.
Gallup's Monday afternoon update suggests the initial bounce that Romney received from last week's presidential debate may already be starting to fade.
If only Yahoo news could somehow offer the "latest" by being attached to some kind of worldwide network of computers that sends information around at the speed of light. That would be really cool.

In any case, here's where we are. Obama's approval rating for Gallup AND for Rasmussen is now 51%. Those are good numbers for Barack Obama if they're real.

Now, those are tracking polls and I'll be the first to criticize those two polling organizations for being ... well, not good. But, until we see some actual evidence (good polls) showing Romney with some massive surge, I wish news organizations would stop saying it's happening.

Sunday, October 7, 2012

Gingrich: Yeah, Mitt's Lying

... Well, he didn't quite say that but he did say that Mitt has flip-flopped.



I don't think these Sunday talk shows matter all that much in the overall battle for the White House but today's Meet the Press certainly didn't help Romney either.

Monitoring the Debate Bounce II

I mentioned yesterday that one reason Democrats shouldn't get too panicked about the post-debate polling is that Romney's gains seem to be just that ... gains for Romney rather than a drop in support for Obama.

This morning, Gallup released their tracker which now includes close to 50% of their sample as post-debate interviews and the topline was unchanged from yesterday (Obama leads 49-46). Similarly, Rasmussen released their tracker which now includes 100% post-debate interviews and their numbers were unchanged from yesterday as well (Romney leads 49-47).

If we use these new numbers to extrapolate out the size of the bounce the same way I did yesterday, we find that Romney got a 4-point bounce in Rasmussen's tracker and is headed for a modest 2-point bounce from Gallup. Average the two and you get a 3-point bounce overall.

But, as I mentioned above, the gains seem to be gains for Romney rather than a drop in support for Obama. Obama's job approval rating in Rasmussen's tracker was 49% before the debate and it is 50% today. The President's job approval has ticked down in Gallup's tracker since the debate but it is still 48%.

Overall, today's numbers (so far) seem to suggest a leveling-off of Romney's post-debate surge. Whether it is just because it has reached its half-life or because the jobs report news is starting to mute it, I think it is starting to look more like it is in line with the 1-2 point bounce I initially predicted.

UPDATE: The Reuters/Ipsos tracker is also unchanged from yesterday (Obama leads 47-45) and that tracker is now almost entirely made up of interviews from after the debate. So, the post-debate Romney bounce seems to be cresting at about 3%.

Saturday, October 6, 2012

Monitoring the Debate Bounce

Some polls have come out since the debate and all of them show Romney getting at least some bounce from the debate. Obviously, by definition, they don't tell us anything about how lasting a bounce would be but we also don't yet have much clarity on the size of the bounce. Let's take a look at what's been happening:

1) Today, Gallup's tracking poll moved from Obama +5 to Obama +3. Gallup uses a 7-day rolling sample so they've only got essentially 2 nights (Thursday night and Friday night) of post-debate sampling in there. The last Gallup tracker that had (almost) NO post-debate respondents was Thursday morning's release and Obama was up 4 in that poll. So, Romney gained a point in the two days since. Let's pretend for a moment that Romney's gains will continue to be the same in a linear fashion (this is very questionable but let's just go with it for now) as the rest of the sample becomes a post-debate sample and it would mean that Romney would go from Obama +4 to Obama +0.5 by next Thursday morning.

2) Rasmussen's tracking poll had Obama ahead by 2 in their Thursday morning release and Romney is up by 2 points in this morning's release. Rasmussen uses a 3-day rolling sample so, approximately two-thirds of their sample is post-debate respondents at this point. If we extrapolate that data the same way we did with the Gallup data, we would have it going from Obama +2 to Romney +4.

3) Reuters/Ipsos has an online tracking poll (pretty questionable methodologically) and they seem to use a 5-day rolling sample. Their poll had Obama ahead by 5 prior to the debate and now has 3 days of post-debate data and has Obama ahead by 2. If we extrapolate that out, we would have them tied by the time they have a full sample of post-debate interviews.

There have also been some state-level polls that show Romney gaining ground but they are almost all from Rasmussen, We Ask America, and Gravis Marketing and the results are little more mixed in terms of what they tell us about a Romney bounce than their topline numbers suggest. Anyway, taking the numbers above, we see the bounce looking like this:

Gallup - 3.5 points
Rasmussen - 6 points
Reuters/Ipsos - 5 points

Average - 4.83 points

If that's right, that would be about the biggest post-debate bounce ever. Is it possible that that is what's happening? Yes, though it is still not likely. But, even if it does happen that way, here's several reasons Democrats shouldn't panic:

1) Even if the effect of the debate is this large, some of it will fade. Remember how the 47% thing was going to be the end of Romney? The first debate's effect will have its own half-life and all of it won't last through Nov. 6. Other things will happen (more debates for one).

2) Remember that these tracking polls are bleeding out old samples on the back end as new samples come in. What we're seeing could be the effect of overly strong samples for Obama leaving the tracker on the back end as much as Romney getting a boost on the post-debate side. Now, that's not likely to explain all of this bounce. But it could explain a small part of it.

3) Obama was leading by about 4 points in most polling averages prior to the debate. Indeed, as described above, he was leading by 4 points and 2 points and 5 points in the Gallup, Rasmussen, and Reuters trackers. So this would make the race about even nationally. It would hurt, but it would not be the end for Obama.

4) I have emphasized the margins here but the news is less bad when you look at Obama's numbers alone. Here's the movement in the three polls for Obama's numbers:

Gallup - No movement (from 49 to 49)
Rasmussen - Negative 2 (from 49 to 47)
Reuters - Negative 2 (from 48 to 46)

Assuming these trends continue (as calculated above), Obama will end up somewhere between 45 (Reuters) and 49 (Gallup) in all these polls. Ipsos pollster, Julia Clark said,
We haven't seen additional gains from Romney. This suggests to me that this is more of a bounce than a permanent shift
She continued
while the debate was effective in energizing the Republican base and giving Romney a boost, it didn't fundamentally change perceptions of either man a great deal.
Taking everything here together, it seems to me that the calculations I've done above effectively represent a worst-case scenario for the effect of the debate for Obama. I continue to think the effect of the debate will not be very large and that we won't really know for sure until we see some better, systematic, non-tracking polls done. Specifically, I think it will be half or less of what the estimate above indicates and even some of that will fade.

We should know soon enough what the right answer is but, in the meantime, the points I outline above are reasons why people shouldn't panic about the debate just yet.

Friday, October 5, 2012

Big Bird

Sure, Obama didn't do well in the debate. But he's also pretty darn good at finding ways to make lemonade out of the lemons ...



Put that together with the good jobs report and I think the Romney bump is going to be small.

The Jobs Report and the Post-Debate Environment

I moderated a panel on the election last night with Chris Kofinis and Greg Strimple, two nationally prominent political consultants. Kofinis is a Democrat and Strimple is a Republican. One of the striking things about the discussion was how much they agreed on the debate and the post-debate environment. They both felt the debate was a very, very bad night for the President and that Romney was now back in the game after his campaign had been floundering for 60-90 days. I asked them both where the polls would be by early next week. Neither gave a specific number but Kofinis said the race would "tighten" and Strimple seemed to say Romney would get an even bigger boost and that Romney would be tied or even could lead.

This morning, Rasmussen released their daily tracking poll which includes one night of post-debate numbers. The topline numbers were unchanged but Rasmussen did note
The single night of polling conducted after the debate did show some improvement for Romney, but it remains to be seen whether that will continue or if it was merely statistical noise.
In the immediate aftermath of the debate, I said I thought Romney would pick up 1 to 2 points. I still think that's about right.

Then, today's jobs report came out. The economy added 114,000 jobs in September and the BLS revised upward the number of jobs the economy added in July and August. Perhaps most importantly from a political perspective, the unemployment rate dropped below 8% to 7.8% ... exactly where the unemployment rate was in January 2009 when President Obama was inaugurated. So what effect will this have on the race?

First, it helps Obama change the subject from his poor debate performance. The biggest problem with the debate performance was the echo chamber of the media talking about it. That discussion will now be more muted in the media or, at the very least, the media will be talking about the question of "does the jobs report change the subject?" That's what we call a self-fulfilling prophecy folks. Second, the jobs report strengthens the President's argument in the next debate in response to the most important question in the campaign: Are you better off than you were four years ago?

Not only can the President say, "We inherited a disaster and we've now turned the corner." Much of the coverage of the last 30 days has focused on the President's rise in the polls being related to missteps by Governor Romney. What has been under-emphasized in the coverage has been the rise in consumer confidence. One good measure of this is Gallup's Economic Confidence Index.

Today's news is going to continue the trend we see there. And that is good for Obama.

Let me add this one last point: The next debate will be a town hall format and there WILL BE a question where a person stands up and says they are unemployed and want to know "what each of you will do specifically to help people like me." Count on that question. The President should answer the question with some specific things he's doing and planning to do to help. But he should then also pivot to say, "We inherited a mess created by the exact same policies that Governor Romney wants to double down on. And now we've tried it my way for four years and the result has been 5,000,000 private sector jobs added to the economy and we've brought unemployment back down to where it was when they left me with this mess. We shouldn't go back, we should keep going forward."

That's the job the President has for the next debate and this jobs report makes it easier to make that argument.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Post-Debate Panic Among Democrats

Most of my Democratic friends (which is most of my friends) are in full freak-out mode about Obama's debate performance. Some of these people value my opinion on these things. Some of them seek out my opinion not because they believe it but because they figure I'll give them the pro-Obama spin and they just want to be comforted. Still others don't ask me for my opinion because they think I'm an apologist for everything Obama's ever done. Whether you want my opinion or not, here it is:

Settle down people, settle down. Read what John Sides has to say. Or read what Sam Wang has to say.

These are smart people. Very ... professorial. When did THAT become a bad word???

Look, the only way Romney can gain ground is if he wins over some undecided voters or if he wins over some voters "leaning" towards Obama who are persuaded to move. There are VERY few undecided voters out there. If half of them made up their minds tonight (not likely) and those people break for Romney 5 to 1 (not likely) ... he picks up a net of about a point to a point and a half. How many of those "leaning" towards Obama changed their mind? Not a lot. Could Romney gain 2 points? It's possible but 1 point is a better bet.

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

What Should Romney Do?

Romney has edged a smidge higher heading into the debate. He's still behind by more than he was before the conventions. And, despite what you hear from Republicans who think the polls are skewed, Romney was already behind before the conventions. Here's the full picture:



The last time Romney led in ANY national poll was back in mid-September in a Rasmussen poll. The last non-Rasmussen national poll where Romney led was in early September (ARG). Romney hasn't been even in the rolling average of polls since May, while he was enjoying his post-nomination "glow."

The structure of the race has been remarkably stable. The odds are that the structure of the race does not change after tonight.

So, how would I advise Romney were I to advise him? Some argue that the description of the data above is what is leading Romney's advisors to tell him to "go big or go home." They are supposedly prepping him with "zingers" and generally, the media is arguing this is Romney's "last, best chance." This is all wrong.

My advice to Romney would flow from this simple, yet harsh, observation. Mitt, the more people see of you, the less they like you. Romney's best bet is to fade into the background and let the election be about Obama. People are dissatisfied with the direction of the country and with Washington in general. Let the campaign be about that. What this means for the debate is that Romney would be smart to be who he is: boring, non-memorable, vague on policy details, etc.

This is the opposite of what we're seeing Romney's advisors say he'll do. But I think it is right. Now, don't get me wrong. This strategy does not guarantee a Romney win by any means. It is simply the best of the bad options in front of Romney right now. He needs to get out of his own way and let Obama sink or swim on the perceptions voters have of him and the direction of the country.

I'll send you a bill in the mail Mitt.